Suche
Mein Konto
Stricter gun controls instead of general knife ban: the German debate about security and individual freedom
In this article, the debate about the ban on dangerous knife types and the wearing of jumping knives and knives with fixed blade from a length of six centimeters are discussed. It is questioned whether a general ban on wearing knives in public space leads to more security and whether the necessary extent of controls can be implemented. The proposal of an amnesty for the delivery of prohibited stab weapons is viewed as a charming alternative. It is also pointed out to the selective implementation of controls and possible abuse of power. Furthermore, it is emphasized that many knife attacks take place in private rooms and that the planned ban would not be sufficient. From the perspective of well -known criminologists and statistics, different aspects of the debate are examined.
Stricter gun controls instead of general knife ban: the German debate about security and individual freedom
new considerations on gun law: Why Interior Minister Faeser's proposal is doubtful
Interior Minister Faeser recently submitted suggestions to tighten the gun right. Among other things, your plan includes a general ban on wearing knives in public space. This measure is intended to increase security, but there is reason for skepticism.
It is undeniable that the possession of some dangerous knife types is already illegal, and for good reason. However, the question arises as to why wearing jumping knives and knives with a fixed blade from a length of six centimeters is still allowed. This should also be in principle prohibited from how it is required by many federal states.
A general ban on carrying knife in public space, however, seems questionable. The police union has already pointed out that the extent of controls required for this can not be implemented. In a democracy it is also not a wish that the police are omnipresent.
The police proposal is the proposal of the police union to introduce an amnesty for the voluntary submission of banned stab weapons and to set incentives for the delivery of non -banned knives. This measure has already shown positive experiences. By targeted controls, arbitrary procedures and abuse of power can be avoided.
It is important to note that the statistics on knife attacks have only existed since 2021 and is prone to manipulation. Well -known criminologists also point out that many knife attacks take place in private rooms, where the proposed ban would not apply.
The debate about weapons law and the security of the citizens is complex and requires differentiated solutions. A general ban on carrying knife in public space therefore does not seem to be the optimal solution. Instead, measures should be taken that aim at preventive information, targeted controls and the provision of support for potential perpetrators.